When a senior leader declares “no case to answer” while a safeguarding review is still live, it doesn’t just shape headlines — it risks shaping outcomes. Why narrative control is no substitute for accountability.
If safeguarding was “managed well”, where are the records? In his own words, Stephen Cottrell relies on memory over evidence, convenience over process, and reassurance over accountability. Safeguarding doesn’t work like that.
“No case to answer” sounds final — but this decision rewrote the rules, excused serious safeguarding failures, and ignored conflicts of interest. It exposes a system not fit for purpose, and a leadership crisis that cannot be shrugged off.
When given a clear opportunity to apologise, show lessons had been learned and provide moral leadership, Stephen Cottrell and Sarah Mullally chose to walk by on the other side. Read how safeguarding rhetoric collapses when Church leaders are confronted with real accountability.
The regulator has spoken: safeguarding in the Church of England is failing, and trustees are now on notice. Real reform needs real accountability at the top.
“In the past, the Church of England has been too quick to protect its own reputation and slow to admit its failings. This must change. Those in public office should be subject to scrutiny.” – Archbishop Stephen Cottrell
“When we make mistakes . . . part of the culture change is to be open and transparent about that as followers of Jesus Christ” – Archbishop Stephen Cottrell